Intriguing facts about
Philip’s life
Because we
don’t know where he was born and because we have very few information about his
life before and even after he arrived in Canada in 1783, we are left with many
unanswered questions. I don’t expect, over the years, to find answers to the
majority of these interrogations.
I am
convinced that devoted members of our family have already found most of the
vital documents about him. Nobody will come up in the near future with a file
detailing the events of his whole life, from his birth to his death. There are
reasons why it is difficult to gather more information on Philip Long who lived
in the 18th century at widely different places before he settled
down in Lac Témiscouata, Qc.
First, like most people at that time, Philip was not highly educated: he
could barely sign his name. He didn’t leave behind any personal writing. Most
of the significant documents about him come from his relationship with
British officers
while he was a public servant.
Second, Philip lived in a time where the recording of information about citizens was still crude. In
fact, the church, and not the government, did the major recording of vital
information during the time Philip was living in Canada.
Third, Philip lived at a time where communities were being established. The first arrivers were, for the
most part, living on their own with no help from the outside. They had received
a land grant in remote places where they had to concentrate their efforts on
surviving above all.
Fourth, it took many years for church and civil officials to offer regular
services to all the
communities spread in an area. For instance, the priest or the minister of a
church would visit the communities a few times a year, even when a church was
built in an area. The recording of the major family events was only done when
the family was able to travel to a regional church, either for a baptism or for
a marriage.
Fifth, some documents about Philip’s life are very revealing about who he
was. For instance, he received a parcel of land in Meductic NB, like the other
Loyalists who came in Canada in 1783. That land grant tells us that he was a
Loyalist. The muster rolls showing his name tell us that he was a Loyalist
soldier. But, most of these documents are related to the period of time following
his arrival in
Canada.
Sixth, before Philip got married with Julie Couillard, he was spotted in
different places. It’s only after his marriage that the build-up of documents
started. Before, he was more or less a nomad. During this period of his life, it is clear
that he didn’t leave « traces » in civil or religious institutions.
Specific questions about Philip Long’s life
For these
major reasons, we are left with uncertainties that have developed over time
into hard-edged questions. Let me list a few. I’m sure that you have already formulated the
majority of them, if not more.
(1)
If he
was a Loyalist,
why did Philip moved to Quebec instead of staying in St. John, Fredericton or
any community in Nova Scotia where the Loyalists were getting organized into
communities? Why was he more attracted towards Quebec than Nova Scotia?
(2)
Why
did he choose to marry a French-speaking girl instead of an English-speaking girl? Was he
already able to speak French when he met Julie Couillard?
(3)
What
kind of training and background prepared him for carrying mail from Quebec to Fredericton an average of
nine times a year for 19 years in a row, at a time when he was over 50 years
old? The distance is 600 Km, one way.
(4)
Why
did he choose to become a long-distance mail carrier instead of a farmer, for instance?
At one time, he lived in Quebec City with his wife and two young children.
Surely, there were job opportunities less challenging than carrying mail on an
incredible distance.
(5)
If he
had been born on American soil, why did John Mann, a journalist arriving from
Scotland, wrote that Philip spoke English with propriety? He should have spoken English with
fluency.
(6)
The oral
tradition of our
family is not extensive. Moreover, our current knowledge casts doubts about
many aspects of it, if not all of it. The oral tradition is quite specific
about his birth country, but not at all informative about his life soon after.
I would expect the opposite.
(7)
We
have had reasons to believe that Philip was born either in England, in United
States or even in Scotland. Nobody has, yet, been able to find a birth
certificate in
those countries that would fit him reasonably well. Are we looking in the right
place? If you have on hand a sensible birth certificate, send it to me,
and I’ll pay the postage!
(8)
He was
supposed to have left to his heirs a fortune. All the documents we have point in the
opposite direction. This legend of the 20th century proved to be
false, a hoax.
(9)
The
children of Philip and Julie didn’t know the precise age of their parents. The age on their
respective birth certificate is an approximation made by the priest. How could
these same children know that he was born in Scotland and had immigrated in
Pennsylvania?
(10) While writing to a British
commander, he talks about His King and His Country. Why not talk about Our King and
Our Country if he was a Loyalist? Was Philip referring to a different King and
Country?
(11) From many sources, it is clear that
Philip was much older than his wife Julie? Why did he get married so late in life?
His military career, from our documentation, cannot be a restraining factor,
because he seemed to have been in loyalist regiments from 1781 to 1783 only.
Could it be that his military career had started much sooner? Was he part of
the British army before the ARW started?
(12) If we compare the civil, military
and religious documents about him, it seems to me that the military ones tell us more about his possible
origins than the other two sources.
(13) A recent DNA test tells us that our ancestors are
from Central Europe in a region including Germany and adjacent countries. WOW.
It seems that we have been looking in the wrong place since the beginning of
this research in 1923.
(14) If you don’t stay close to the
documentation
gathered over the years about Philip, you will slowly slide from facts to fiction.
All kinds of predictions have been running around about Philip’s origins. Some
of us are convinced that he was born in a particular country, while others put
him somewhere else. Each one of us has his own hypothesis about it. And that’s
alright. But where is your documentation to back your hypothesis? Is it a « gut
feeling » or something more elaborate?
(15) I don’t have to tell you that many
aspects of Philip’s life will never be uncovered, simply because there are no
traces or documents about it. But, there should be a birth certificate
somewhere. I’ll never stop searching, because I’m convinced there is one. I’m not searching for the size
of his boots, but for his birth certificate. Let’s not loose sight of
common sense along the way.
These
questions can serve to spark your interest about my ancestor. You might not be
interested, though, to make any effort in finding his birthplace. That’s
perfectly acceptable. But, if you
simply want to learn more about him, it means that you are part of our
adventure. I appreciate any level of participation in this long-lasting research
project.